Bathtub Remodel: Should You Replace, Refinish, or Reglaze?

Let’s talk about your bathtub. It’s seen things—bubble baths, toddler tantrums, that one time you tried to dye your hair purple and ended up looking like a Smurf. But now, it’s looking a little worse for wear. Chips, stains, and a general aura of neglect have turned your once-gleaming tub into a sad, dingy eyesore.  

So, what’s the move? Should you replace it, refinish it, or reglaze it? Spoiler: Each option has its pros and cons (and price tags). Here’s my proper guide to help you decide so that you can improve your bathtub with the help of the best Bathtub Remodel Service.  

1. Replace Your Bathtub (The Nuclear Option)

Replacing your bathtub is like getting a divorce—it’s a big decision, but sometimes it’s the only way to start fresh.  

What It Involves: 

- Ripping out the old tub and installing a new one.  

- Potentially reconfiguring plumbing and tile work.  

- A lot of dust, noise, and possibly tears.  

Cost: $1,500–$5,000+ (depending on the tub and labor).  

Pros:  

- You get a brand-new tub (duh).  

- Endless options for styles, materials, and features (hello, soaking tub).  

- Increases your home’s resale value.  

Cons:  

- Very expensive.  

- Messy and time-consuming (we’re talking days, not hours).  

- Might require permits and professional help.  

If your tub is beyond repair or you’re doing a full bathroom remodel, go for it. Otherwise, maybe explore other options.  

2. Refinish Your Bathtub (The Middle Ground)

Refinishing is like giving your tub a facelift—it’s not brand new, but it looks damn good.  

What It Involves:  

- Sanding down the existing surface.  

- Applying a new coating (usually epoxy or acrylic).  

- Letting it cure for 24–48 hours.  

Cost: $300–$600 (DIY) or $500–$1,000 (professional).  

Pros:  

- Much cheaper than replacement.  

- Restores your tub to like-new condition.  

- Can be done in a day or two.  

Cons:  

- The finish may chip or wear over time (especially if you’re rough on your tub).  

- Strong fumes during the process (open a window, please).  

- Not a permanent fix (expect to redo it every 5–10 years).  

If you’re DIY-ing, invest in a high-quality refinishing kit. The $20 one from Walmart won’t cut it.  

3. Reglaze Your Bathtub (The Quick Fix)

Reglazing is like slapping on a fresh coat of paint—it’s quick, easy, and makes a big difference.  

What It Involves:  

- Cleaning and prepping the tub surface.  

- Spraying on a new glaze (usually polyurethane or epoxy).  

- Letting it dry for 24 hours.  

Cost: $200–$500 (professional only—DIY reglazing is a disaster waiting to happen).  

Pros:  

- Cheaper than refinishing or replacing.  

- Fast turnaround (done in a day).  

- Hides stains, scratches, and minor imperfections.  

Cons:  

- Less durable than refinishing (expect to redo it every 3–5 years).  

- Limited color options (usually just white or off-white).  

- Requires professional help (DIY kits are notoriously bad).  

If you’re selling your home soon and just need a quick update, reglazing is your best bet.  

4. How to Decide (Because Overthinking is My Hobby)

Still unsure? Here’s a quick cheat sheet:  

- Replace if:  

  - Your tub is cracked, leaking, or beyond repair.  

  - You’re doing a full bathroom remodel.  

  - You want to upgrade to a fancier tub (soaking, jetted, etc.).  

- Refinish if:  

  - Your tub is structurally sound but looks like it’s been through a war.  

  - You want a long-lasting solution without the cost of replacement.  

  - You’re okay with a little DIY effort (or hiring a pro).  

- Reglaze if:  

  - You’re on a tight budget and timeline.  

  - You’re selling your home and need a quick update.  

  - Your tub has minor cosmetic issues (stains, scratches, etc.).  

5. Hidden Costs (Because Surprises Are the Worst)

No matter which option you choose, there are always hidden costs. Here’s what to watch out for:  

- Permits: Some cities require permits for bathtub replacement.  

- Plumbing: Replacing a tub might mean updating your plumbing (cha-ching).  

- Tile Work: If your new tub is a different size, you might need to redo the tile.  

- Ventilation: Refinishing and reglazing require good airflow (fumes are no joke).  

Get multiple quotes before committing. And always read the fine print.  

Final Thought:

Your bathtub is the centerpiece of your bathroom, so it’s worth investing in. Whether you replace, refinish, or reglaze, the goal is the same: a tub you’re proud to soak in.